Council Rift Widens Over Dallas City Hall and Possible Mavericks Arena
Share News:
Members of the Dallas City Council remain divided over the fate of City Hall and are pressing their respective cases as to the integrity of the process underlying staff’s efforts to explore relocation and redevelopment options.
On Sunday, Mayor Eric Johnson offered his most forceful response to those who have been speculating that officials and private interests are colluding to stack the deck against a full repair of 1500 Marilla St. to clear the way for redevelopment.
“Those who are more interested in muddying the waters than dealing in facts are working overtime, trying to make normal stuff sound nefarious,” Johnson said in a newsletter, defending the work of the staff members and consultants who produced a property condition assessment report on what it would take to restore the I.M. Pei-designed base of city operations and get it move-in ready.
As previously reported by CandysDirt.com, the report concluded it would cost as much as $1 billion across 20 years to get the job done, a figure many local preservationists, architects, and other skeptics claim is inflated. Others, including members of the city council, have also lambasted the process as rushed and lacking transparency.
“It is ironic that some of the same voices who most loudly demanded an outside facility condition assessment are now the loudest critics of the result,” Johnson said. “Perhaps it is they who only wanted a report that would support the position they had staked out while operating with — in their own words — insufficient information.”
Some council members indeed took a relatively hard stance early on, particularly Council Members Cara Mendelsohn (District 12) and Paul Ridley (District 14), who didn’t believe staff’s initial estimates and wanted a thorough professional assessment done.
All the drama surrounding City Hall has appeared to put the mayor and Mendelsohn at odds. Typically seen as allies across a range of issues, the pair are now divided over what could be one of the most consequential questions facing Dallas. A big factor at play in that decision may very well be where the Dallas Mavericks build their new arena.
The Mavericks said an unidentified property downtown (widely believed to be 1500 Marilla St.) and the former Valley View Center in North Dallas are on their shortlist for preferred sites.
Over the past week or so, Mendelsohn, who represents Far North Dallas, has taken to publicly calling for Valley View as the best site, arguing that a TIF district would direct badly needed funds to southern Dallas and preserve the trust of residents who feel officials are rolling out the red carpet to the Mavericks.
“City Hall is not for sale because it looks like we’ll probably just give it away,” Mendelsohn said at a meeting earlier this month. “This land will be cursed. It will haunt whatever organization occupies the space, and what I do know is we don’t know the whole story.”
In a number of social media posts this past week, Mendelsohn argued that the city can’t afford to lease office space if it relocated operations and that the Mavericks just needed to make a deal with Valley View’s owners.
Johnson said that no deal structure has been presented to the city council yet, not from the Mavericks or any other potential developer eyeing the site.
“So there’s no basis to characterize an entirely unknown — and as yet, hypothetical — deal as a ‘giveaway,’” he said, noting, however, that the city “will do everything reasonably in its power” to keep the Mavericks in town.
Johnson also pointed out that no matter where a new Mavericks arena lands, there will be developers, business owners, and workers who benefit from the project in one way or another.
Much has been made by critics of relocation about the push by downtown stakeholders to call for redeveloping 1500 Marilla St. Bazaldua and Mendelsohn raised the issue during the city council’s last meeting, going so far as to propose banning property owners within three-quarters of a mile of City Hall from participating in any solicitations related to relocation or redevelopment.
“So it’s unclear why some council members feel the need to vilify developers with interests around City Hall while supporting a different possible arena site that would simply benefit a different set of developers,” he said. “Maybe someone will find that worth reporting on.”
All this controversy isn’t expected to end anytime soon. Staff have been directed to continue exploring relocation and redevelopment and flesh out different repair scenarios. Meanwhile, internal city emails obtained by The Dallas Morning News are shedding light on how staff went about assessing the condition of 1500 Marilla St. and lining up potential alternatives.
Much is at stake here, and not just for the building itself. Trust in city government has been frayed somewhat, and a lot of hopes are pinned on relocation as a catalyst for transformative redevelopment in the southern part of downtown and the neighborhoods just across I-30.
“The City Council must figure out what to do with City Hall. It’s unfortunate that the current building doesn’t work as intended and the vision for a thriving government district never materialized. But that is where we are,” Johnson said. “At the same time, it must fight to keep the Mavericks in the city of Dallas. Those are the facts. It’s time to put aside the pettiness and start talking about a real vision for this city’s future.
Johnson got the ball rolling on the City Hall question after staff briefed council members on all the deferred maintenance that has accumulated. The mayor subsequently created the Finance Committee to evaluate whether the city’s vast real estate portfolio — including City Hall — was effectively supporting city operations and best serving residents.
Earlier this year, the Finance Committee voted unanimously to recommend directing the city manager to pursue relocation and redevelopment options for City Hall. The full city council subsequently adopted an amended resolution to “explore” rather than “pursue” those options as well as game out repair scenarios.
Additionally, the city council added language requiring staff to determine whether any companies involved in producing the property condition assessment could have a conflict of interest if they participate in future solicitations related to the sale or redevelopment of 1500 Marilla St.
Mayor Johnson and Council Members Chad West (District 1), Jesse Moreno (District 2), Zarin Gracey (District 3), Maxie Johnson (District 4), Jaime Resendez (District 5), Lori Blair (District 8), and Kathy Stewart (District 10) voted in favor of continuing the exploratory work.
Bazaldua, Blackmon, Mendelsohn, Ridley, Roth, and Laura Cadena (District 6) voted against the amended resolution.
4 Comments
Leave a Comment
Sure City Hall land is for sale
Minimum bid must be $6 billion+
Funds from sale of City Hall must be used to maintain other City Owned property or pay down debt, or fund pension funds.
To be honest I don’t trust basically anything, that comes from the mayor and the majority of council members are grossly incompetent. I am coming up with those feeling by just watching what’s going on in my city that I have lived in for the last 60 years. Our roads are crap, code enforcement is a joke. Your say some old crazy white guy from north Dallas, well maybe, but I drive all over Dallas daily. I see yards that have not been mowed in months, fences that are coming down, trash around night clubs. I’m over in west Dallas weekly why has it taken almost two years to repairs some streets over there. Here is a example on South Ravinia why has it taken TWO months to receive bulk trash pickup. Three week ago I was house sitting for a friend, count 17 gunshots at 6:25 am on a Sunday morning, called 911, provided all the information asked, told the nice young woman, it happen in front of the house and even gave descriptions of the cars involved, the Police never showed up. The biggest mess, the homeless in downtown, more than likely the reason ATT moved to Plano, per friends that work there. Alot of people say nothing like that happens in North Dallas, you are so wrong. Cant go to the Kroger on Midway and Frankford after its dark. Panhandlers on the majority of the street intersections. We now have bars that are open still 2 am with loud music until 3am in the parking lots, no action from 311 or 911. To me Dallas seams to becoming the new Detroit. We the fine citizens that live in our city are paying a lot in property taxes and sales taxes. And now they are trying to tear down city hall with what I would call highly inflated numbers. If the Maveric’s want a new Area, there are two open choices for them: Where Reunion Arean used to be and where Valley View Mall used to be. Then we need to get the city council member out who are in the pockets of the developers.
After the council bought the lemon on Stemmons ($14M purchase + $6M repairs) and the “hotel for the homeless” in South Dallas ($6M) only to abandon both projects for lack of due diligence, they now except the citizens of Dallas to trust their decision making? Mayor Johnson is a joke and the council members are ill equipped to handle any financial decisions. Any report can say what you want it to say (like a billion dollars in repairs) to get what you want. And why build something new when it’s been proven city management can’t take care of it. Move into the AT&T building, when once again Dallas loses a major company to the suburbs, and let the management of that building take care of it. Dallas management is too inept to handle anything more than meetings.
Pool Bear on March 16, 2026 at 4:45 pm
Brilliantly said and stated.
Thank you
Cynthia Lucas