David Preziosi: The Struggle to Save Historic Homes is Real

Share News:

Saved! 3805 McFarlin (Photo: Michael Cagle)

David Preziosi, FAICP
Executive Director, Preservation Dallas

It has always been a struggle in Dallas and the Park Cities to save historic homes from the wrecking ball. We have lost so much over the years and continue to do so because historic properties face incredible pressure, from property valuations to a desire for increased density.  The bigger, bolder, newer philosophy has often been the mantra regarding buildings in Dallas and the Park Cities, whether residential or commercial. 

historic homes
This historic home at 3805 McFarlin has incredible details inside and out.

However, the historic preservation community received excellent news last week.  An announcement was made that the 1931 Elbert Williams House at 3805 McFarlin Boulevard in University Park was purchased, not for demolition, but preservation.  

The Williams house was designed by architect David Williams (no relation to Elbert Williams). He is considered the originator of the Texas Regionalism style. The style incorporated local materials and logical designs to deal with Texas’s harsh climate. Broad overhangs shaded interiors, while first- and second-story porches and large windows allowed for maximum airflow before air conditioning came along.

O’Neil Ford, a protégé of David Williams, used the style extensively with numerous examples built in Dallas and the Park Cities.  

The Penson House at 3756 Armstrong Parkway, designed by O’Neil Ford, was demolished by Lute Riley after being sold at auction.

Thankfully, the incredibly important Williams house will remain.

However, many other historic homes have not been as lucky, including many designed by O’Neil Ford.

Both the Park Cities and Dallas have lost significant and unique historic houses with a plethora in the last few years. It can be an uphill battle to save a historic home with the incredible development pressure the area continues to face year after year.  

While there are historic and conservation districts in Dallas to protect historic structures, there is no equivalent in the Park Cities.

A property owner in the Park Cities can demolish a residence that has stood for decades, sometimes even a century or more, without any review, other than requiring a demolition permit. That has unfortunately led to a dwindling supply of historic homes in the Park Cities. 

Both in Dallas and the Park Cities, property values have increased to the point where the land can be more valuable than the historic house that sits on it. This, unfortunately, makes it even harder to save historic homes from the wrecking ball, especially if the home is on a large lot. Developers target them because they are prime for subdivision.

In several areas of Dallas, zoning has also been changed over the years in a push for greater density. This has led to historic houses becoming worthless when a lot can go from a single-family structure to a bevy of multi-family units squeezed onto the lot, according to the maximum density and height allowed by law. 

Grand estates such as 5521 Swiss Avenue were at risk before the area’s historic district was formed.

The first residential historic district in Dallas was created to fight just that. In the early 1970s, Swiss Avenue was threatened with upzoning for mid-rise apartments and a TxDOT project cutting through the neighborhood to speed people into downtown.

A proposed mid-rise near Swiss Avenue was the impetus for the first residential historic district.

The area was run down at the time, and the grand revival houses were dilapidated and unsightly. That stretch of some of the most incredible revival houses in the city could have been lost if it was not for the neighborhood property owners banning together to fight the changes and to protect it with historic district status. 

The Swiss Avenue Historic District became the first residential historic district in Dallas in 1974 and laid the groundwork for the 20 historic districts that followed. Surely today, there isn’t anyone who could argue that it was not a successful venture as the Swiss Avenue Historic District is one of the most incredible and successful historic districts in the city. 

Historic homes can be brought back to life with vision and time.

Another factor in the demise of historic houses is that it is sometimes difficult for people to see past the condition of a non-renovated historic home. Even with the plethora of DIY and house flipping shows, most people still have trouble getting past peeling paint, rotten wood, sagging floors, caving ceilings, building systems that don’t work, and floor plans that don’t make sense for modern living.

They see scrapping and starting over as the only option. Yes, some houses can be past the point of no return when it comes to renovation, but one would be surprised by how many homes can come back from the brink of extinction.  

historic homes
Demolished: The Bud Oglesby-designed home at 10300 Strait Lane

It can take a lot to envision the possibilities for a house when it is in that condition. For those lacking that vision, there are plenty of people who have it, from architects to contractors to developers. Preservation Dallas has lists of those talented folks to help property owners explore rehabilitation and options versus demolition. 

In both Dallas and the Park Cities, there are incredible examples of historic houses and buildings that have been brought back to life and updated for modern living.

Last month, Preservation Dallas held its 21st annual Preservation Achievement Awards and celebrated outstanding preservation projects and the people doing preservation work. To date, there have been over 300 awards given out. 

The Parks Estate of East Dallas won a Preservation Achievement Award in 2009.

It is incredible to see the breadth of these award-winning projects from small to large, residential to commercial, and from rehabilitation to restoration. The people that have worked on these projects are as varied as the type of projects themselves, from first-timers to seasoned renovators, and include property owners, architects, contractors, and developers. 

The awards not only recognize those doing the work, but they also serve as inspiration for others who may be on the fence about taking on a similar project.

As with any construction project, it is not for the faint of heart as there can be surprises and setbacks along the way, just like in new construction, but you have to keep your eye on the prize. Often these projects become a labor of love for those undertaking them and make one feel more connected to the house and saving its history for the future.

The award-winning projects prove that hurdles can be overcome and that historic houses can have a new life in this modern world. 

mm

CandysDirt.com Contributor

CandysDirt.com welcomes articles and op-eds from our readers and brand partners. Think you have a great story to tell? Send us a note at news@candysdirt.com.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jaynie Schultz says

    Thank you, David, and everyone working so hard for preservation. Your point about demolition for density is well-taken and must be considered when allowing density increases. We must balance both.
    I wish people could explore preservation before moving to demolition. It hurts neighborhoods, not just the home.

  2. Kristi Sheffy says

    Thank you for all the hard work! It always makes me sad when an old home is demolished. There is always the inner potential to make them grand again. I appreciate all those with the vision and determination to go forward with these wonderful projects.

  3. Leah Shafer says

    David, I applaud your hard work! This is vitally important. I would love to see more attention to the Tenth Street Historic District Freedmans Town on the eastern edge of Oak Cliff. As one of the only remaining intact Freedman’s Towns in the nation, it is particularly important from a historic and cultural perspective. I remember Preservation Dallas was active there in the early 2000s. Would there be a possibility of focusing more in 2021?

    • mmKaren Eubank says

      Hi Leah! Yes, we are trying to provide as much historic preservation coverage as possible. I don’t’ believe there is another media outlet in America with a weekly column devoted to historic preservation. We have done several stories on Tenth Street with the most recent here: https://candysdirt.com/?s=Tenth+Street. We also hope to have more guest columns from David as well! If you have any ideas do send them my way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *